Love at First Slice

The best pizza in Chicago

There's no shortage of great pizza in Chicago—it's just that kind of town. And while deep dish may be the city's claim to fame, there are plenty of other pizzas worth seeking out, from newfangled Neapolitan pies to cracker-thin Sicilian slices. Here are 8 of our favorites.

Pequod's Pizza in Lincoln Park
A departure from traditional deep-dish pies, Pequod's pan pizzas ($6.96 to $17.50, plus toppings) are baked in a seasoned cast-iron skillet and offer a crust-to-cheese ratio that leans toward the crisp, caramelized crust's favor. Keep it simple with a single topping, like pepperoni or sausage.

Pat's Pizza in Lincoln Park
This no-frills, family-owned pizza joint has been tossing thin crust pizzas since the 1950s, and shows no sign of slowing. Cross (most of) the major food groups off with the signature Pat's Special ($15.50 to $22.45), which arrives loaded with sausage, mushrooms, green peppers and onions.

Lou Malnati's (multiple locations)
One of Chicago's most quintessential deep-dish slingers, Lou's is a time-tested favorite among many pizza purists. The Malnati Chicago Classic ($14.75 to 23.95) comes with crumbly sausage, extra cheese and tangy tomato sauce on a flaky, buttery crust that's a legend in its own right.

Piece in Wicker Park
New Haven-style "apizza" with a thin, chewy crust is the name of the game at this pizzeria, which doubles as an award-winning brewery.  The Plain pie comes slathered in tomato sauce with garlic and Parmesan, while the Red is all that plus a layer of gooey mozzarella, and the White nixes tomatoes entirely ($12.49 to $18.94). 

Coalfire in West Loop
Keep it simple with Coalfire's thin-crust Margherita ($15) with marinara, fresh mozzarella and basil. After assembly, pizzas are blasted in an 800-degree coal oven and emerge with perfectly charred, bubbly crusts that impart a subtle smoky flavor in each bite.

Pizzeria da Nella in Lincoln Park
Da Nella's traditional wood-fired Neapolitan pizzas—stretched and topped by Naples native Nella Grassano herself—are the closest you'll get to the real deal without hopping a flight to Italy. The Sorrentina ($13.99), a sauce-free pie with creamy mozzarella di Bufala, sweet cherry tomatoes, basil and olive oil is a favorite, but all of the gloriously flame-blistered pies are worth a try.

Giordano's (multiple locations)
Thanks to their ridiculously cheesy sauce-on-top 'zas, Giordano's reigns as one of the greater Chicagoland area's most ubiquitous, well-loved stuffed pizza purveyors. Sink your teeth into the appropriately named Meat & More Meat ($22.75 to $32.75), packed with pepperoni, salami, sausage and bacon, and clear your schedule for the nap you'll need immediately thereafter.

Vito & Nick's in Ashburn
This old-school institution has been serving thin-crust, square-cut pizzas to hungry South Siders since 1923 ($14.25 to $16.50). The only topping you need to concern yourself with is the rich, fennel-flecked sausage. V&N's has successfully upheld a strict no-delivery policy over the years, but the impeccably executed Sicilian pizzas are well worth the visit.

Pequod's Pizza 2207 N. Clybourn Ave. Chicago IL 60614 773-327-1512 Pat's Pizza 2679 N. Lincoln Ave. Chicago IL 60614 773-248-0168 Lou Malnati's 439 N. Wells St. Chicago IL 60654 312-828-9800 Piece 1927 W. North Ave. Chicago IL 60622 773-772-4422 Coalfire 1321 W. Grand Ave. Chicago IL 60642 312-226-2625 Pizzeria da Nella 1443 W. Fullerton Ave. Chicago IL 60614 773-281-6600 Giordano's 5311 S. Blackstone Ave. Chicago IL 60615 773-947-0200 Vito & Nick's 8433 S. Pulaski Rd. Chicago IL 60652 773-735-2050


Get the Tasting Table newsletter for adventurous eaters everywhere
X Share on FB →

Around the Web