The Brand Behind One Of The Cheapest Yellow Cake Mixes Should Stick To Southern Staples

Add Tasting Table on Google:
Google Discover

We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

So many of us love getting the opportunity to show off our homemade baking skills. It just feels nice to enter a home or gathering with something yummy in hand that looks and tastes like you spent all day making it. It's thrilling to get excited questions from those trying your dessert, asking for your specific recipe, or inquiring about your special ingredient. But nothing beats that feeling when you secretly know what you brought to the party came from a boxed mix. And while many boxed cake mixes might pass as delightfully from scratch, Jiffy Yellow Cake Mix is probably not going to be one of them.

Now we can offer you a recipe for a lovely homemade yellow cake with chocolate frosting, but you may be more interested in the top choices from our ranking of 12 different boxed yellow cake mixes. The original Duncan Hines Classic Yellow Cake Mix got top marks in aroma, texture, and flavor, while Jiffy's version fell quite far down the list for the same reasons. Our reviewer felt the phrase "you get what you pay for" from the moment they started mixing the water and egg into this under-$1 cake mix, which looked mealy and unappealing. Out of the oven, our reviewer noted the cake lacked volume, the texture was strange, and the flavor, while slightly sweet, was nearly nonexistent.

Jiffy's boxed cake mix may have its place in the kitchen after all

While there are those who find Jiffy's cake mix to be less than desirable, there seem to be quite a few who reach for this cake mix box almost religiously. In most cases, though, it doesn't seem to be for the purpose Jiffy intended. For instance, one Redditor highly recommended, "Replace the corn muffin mix in your corn pudding/casserole with Jiffy Yellow Cake Mix for the best corn pudding/casserole ever!" Many in the thread took note, as quite a few were unaware Jiffy even made cake mixes. Others took to sharing their own creative ways to use the cake mix, whether it was a shortcut to the cakey part of cobbler or mixed with a variety of fruit to execute a simple dump cake. Some reviewers even mentioned using it to create cookies, pancakes, waffles, pineapple upside-down cake, and Boston crème pie.

Those who like Jiffy cake mix seem to have their own personal reasons. Jiffy does have a nostalgic pull with many. Some grew up with it as part of family recipes. And others just appreciate that the mix is small enough to satiate one or two people without anything going to waste. So, while it might not be the best boxed yellow cake mix to pick up for a delicious yellow cake, it probably won't be pulled from the shelves any time soon either.

Recommended