20 Popular Pumpkin Beers, Ranked

Autumn's arrival heralds a pumpkin flavor frenzy. From Starbucks' Pumpkin Spice Latte to myriad treats, pumpkin reigns supreme, and a visit to the grocery store shows that pumpkin spice products sprinkle nearly every aisle. So, it's hardly a shock that craft breweries have also jumped on the pumpkin wagon, but the way we picture pumpkin beer today is different from the early days of American brewing. The joy here lies in the diversity — while we all appreciate the classic medley of pumpkin and spice, it's particularly thrilling when a brewery ventures off the beaten path.

With such an expansive range of options, the choice can be dizzying, yet those offerings undeniably stand out from the pack. To narrow down our favorites, we evaluate each option based on the presence of pumpkin, taste of the beer, can or bottle decor and theming, and, of course, the uniqueness factor that sets it apart from other favorite beers. We found that beers often offered pumpkin or spices, but rarely would they have both, and it's even rarer that the beers would have something totally unique. Without further adieu, here's how we ranked them.

Stepping into the realm of bourbon barrel-infused delights, Bottle Logic presents a unique twist on the seasonal pumpkin ale. The marriage of pumpkin and spices with a bourbon barrel aging process results in an experience where spices and the unmistakable bourbon undertones dominate the palate. While the pumpkin essence remains somewhat elusive, it has not vanished entirely.

As for the overall taste, it's intense and assertively bourbon-forward, with the promise of increasing potency as time goes by. The can's decor resonates with nostalgic intrigue with a narrative reminiscent of the "Twilight Zone," yet humorously rebranded as the "Pumpkin Zone." Boasting a robust 12.88% ABV might be too potent for casual sippers, but those with a penchant for bourbon barrel-aged concoctions will undoubtedly find it captivating.

Saint Arnold Pumpkinator also strays from the predictable pumpkin path, choosing instead to delve deeply in another direction. With each sip, it's evident that spices reign supreme in this brew, overshadowing the pumpkin undertones and imparting a rich, enveloping taste. This heavy feel might be a bit much for some, but for those seeking a robust flavor profile, it's an enthralling experience.

Visually, the beer presents itself in a deep, captivating stout hue that promises a taste adventure. The can art does not disappoint either. Saint Arnold's signature playful artwork graces the packaging, with Saint Arnold accentuated with the imagery of a hauntingly detailed haunted house and a menacing jack-o-lantern, tying it perfectly to the Halloween season. With a strong 11.2% ABV, this brew pairs its intense flavors with a kick to match.

Elysian's Imperial Pumpkin Ale presents a more muted interpretation of the seasonal pumpkin ale. The expected pumpkin flavors, which are generally bold in other offerings, are more reserved here. Similarly, the spices, while detectable, are less pronounced, especially when compared to Elysian's own Night Owl.

Visually, the can embodies the season's spirit, showcasing a ghostly jack-o-lantern graphic that gives it a touch of Halloween whimsy. Texture-wise, the ale leans towards a heavier feel, bordering on the syrupy side, which might appeal to those preferring a more full-bodied brew. Despite its 8.4% ABV, the overall experience seems to tread a middle path. It might not stand out in a crowded pumpkin ale field, but its subdued spice presence could make it a suitable choice for those seeking something less intense.

This ale leans more toward the profile of a sweet amber ale punctuated by some subtle spicing. We like this hint of sweetness, and it's nice to taste in a brew for the season. Visually, the can speaks of autumn, with evocative images of pumpkins providing a serene backdrop. While this brew might not be the one to choose for those seeking bold, adventurous flavors, there's an undeniable charm in its simplicity, and the design celebrating the pumpkin more than the jack-o-lantern is also a welcome charming decoration.

A noteworthy aspect of this ale is the inclusion of lactose, which could impart that slightly creamy texture and contribute to its sweet undertone. With a respectable 7.3% ABV, Alewerks Pumpkin Ale is a modest nod to the season, appreciated best by those who seek subtlety over intensity.

Blue Point's Mother Pumpkin Ale is a nod to the essence of raw pumpkin. In a market often dominated by the spices accompanying pumpkin flavors, this brew stands out by allowing the authentic pumpkin taste to shine. It offers an easy-drinking experience with an intriguing touch of floral hops. It doesn't dive deep into the IPA territory but flirts with a hint of hoppiness, which is refreshing and surprising in a pumpkin ale.

The can design, too, is a fun and whimsical concoction; the name Mother Pumpkin is playfully represented by a pumpkin parting to unveil a skeletal surprise. For those weary of the typical pumpkin pie flavor profiles inundating the market, this ale offers a cleaner, more straightforward pumpkin experience. Sitting at 5.5% ABV, it's a brew that might not appease the spice aficionados but will be a treat for genuine pumpkin purists.

Lakefront Brewery's Pumpkin Lager brings a beautifully orchestrated melody of pumpkin and mild spices out of Milwaukee, Wisconsin. This lager lets the pumpkin sing, accentuated just enough by spices like cinnamon, allspice, and ginger without being overpowering. The overall flavor profile is harmoniously balanced, offering a delightful and refreshing palate experience.

The can's aesthetically pleasing presentation features a matte label that lends a sophisticated touch. The clean, minimalistic design of the pumpkin graphic aligns perfectly with the beer's essence, evoking a sense of elegance and simplicity. What distinguishes this lager is its pristine clarity, achieved through filtration, resulting in a drink that's light and devoid of any thickness. Sitting at 6.1% ABV, this lager might leave spice fans yearning for a tad more kick, but its refined pumpkin-forward taste will surely captivate many.

The Tripping Animals Pumpkin Ale is an exploration of contrasts. The pumpkin's presence is subtle at first but becomes more noticeable as it rests on the palate, revealing its depth over time. The spices present a robust flavor that dissipates swiftly, like a brief, flavorful gust of autumn wind.

The can design is an artful juxtaposition of playfulness and intrigue. A possessed-looking raccoon takes center stage and is set against pumpkins that shimmer with a glossy finish, contrasting the matte label. It's an ultra-memorable design. The brown ale distinction further sets this beer apart from its peers. At 6% ABV, the Tripping Animals Pumpkin Ale offers a flavor profile that's layered and distinctive, making each sip a journey of discovery.

In Elysian's Dark 'o the Moon Pumpkin Stout, chocolate notes dominate, punctuated by cinnamon's unexpected yet tasty touch. This distinction from the often-muddled mix of spices in other brews is a refreshing change. The stout's deep hue is almost mesmerizing, with a consistency that's rich and almost velvety.

The can art only adds to the allure. Featuring a werewolf rendered in detailed artwork, it's set against a backdrop of eerie typography, conjuring images of a moonlit Halloween night featuring the latest horror flick. With 7.5% ABV, the stout is robust without being too overpowering. Dark 'o the Moon stands out not just for its flavors but for its approach to a stout that somehow remains reassuringly familiar to those who love dark beers.

Florida Ave's The Lantern Imperial Pumpkin is an ideal middle-ground for those who enjoy a pronounced pumpkin presence without it becoming overwhelming. This brew has an inviting sweetness and feels like a nod to the taste of pumpkin pie. The subtlety of the spices is what sets it apart; they exist in such a mellow mix that accentuates rather than overpowers the overall flavor profile.

Visually, the can is a work of art. It showcases a captivating design that pays homage to the spirit of Halloween. A bevy of hearts and jack-o'-lanterns are deftly woven into the design, surrounded by pumpkin leaves and cinnamon sticks. This creates a festive and a tad eerie tapestry, capturing the dual essence of the season beautifully. With an alcohol content of 8.5%, The Lantern balances taste and potency, offering a distinct take on the classic pumpkin beer.

Elysian takes the cherished taste profile of a pumpkin spice latte and elevates it to the next level with its stout base. The gentle presence of pumpkin blends with rich, aromatic coffee, courtesy of Stumptown, creates a taste profile that's an absolute delight for stout and pumpkin aficionados. Adding depth are hints of cinnamon and nutmeg, reminiscent of that iconic pumpkin spice latte.

The can's artwork is whimsically appropriate. A jack-o-lantern blissfully inhales the aroma of a steaming coffee, all set against a backdrop adorned with spider webs, seamlessly blending the spirit of Halloween with the comfort of a morning brew. Including lactose lends a smoothness to the beer, enriching its body and mouthfeel. At 6% ABV, Punkuccino offers a perfect blend of coffee stout and pumpkin, a nod to the PSL trend and yet another testament to Elysian's craft mastery, particularly when it comes to pumpkin.