The 11 Best Jelly Roll Pans For Your Budget
We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.
A jelly roll pan is guaranteed to be one of the most versatile baking pans you can have in your collection. These pans run smaller (15 inches by 10 inches) than a standard baking pan (18 inches by 13 inches), making it easier to manipulate in a standard-size or small oven. Another key characteristic of the jelly roll pan is the rimmed edges, which are typically around an inch tall, allowing a sheet cake to rise properly and ensuring that the baker nails the perfect ratio of frosting to sponge.
Besides using this pan to make the jelly roll desserts it is aptly named for, it also comes in handy for roasting vegetables, making croutons, and baking brownies with the perfect ratio of crispy edge to gooey center. In short, there's not much that these pans can't do. We've narrowed down some of the best jelly roll pans you can purchase — for all of your kitchen needs.
How we selected products
There are numerous criteria we used to select our top pans. Overall, a good jelly roll pan (or any pan, widely speaking) should be durable and resist warping in the oven. This ensures that you won't have to replace the pan as frequently and that your food cooks evenly on it. We also examined the ease of cleaning for each of these pans to ensure you can spend more time baking and cooking than standing by the sink with a sponge in hand. Not only was cost a consideration for these jelly roll pans, but also the product's overall value. In other words, did the performance of the pan justify its purchase price?
Along with factoring in our own personal experiences, we examined reviews from various customers and other verified outlets to determine our top picks in each category. Although we've done most of the legwork for you, we always recommend researching and examining the pans in person before you commit to a purchase. Here are some of our recommendations for the best-value jelly roll pans you can find.
Best overall jelly roll pan: Williams Sonoma Goldtouch Pro Nonstick Jelly Roll Pan
We love Williams Sonoma for its timeless products and durability, so it's no surprise that the chain's Goldtouch Pro Nonstick Jelly Roll Pan made its way to our top spot. Each pan is made with aluminized steel, which makes it lightweight yet sturdy. The pan is less prone to warping thanks to the reinforced rim.
It is oven-safe up to 450 F, which is perfect for baking or roasting most foods. Plus, Williams Sonoma Goldtouch products are built to conduct and retain heat well, so you should always expect a consistent result with this pan.
Purchase the Goldtouch Pro Nonstick Jelly Roll Pan from Williams Sonoma for $29.95.
Best value jelly roll pan: Nordic Ware Natural Jelly Roll Pan
It's tough to beat the durability and value that Nordic Ware cookware provides, and these lightweight high-quality jelly roll pans are one of the most affordable on the market. The aluminum alloy provides a nonstick surface that conducts and retains heat well and is more scratch-resistant than many of its competitors, while the encapsulated solid core steel rim keeps rusting and warping at bay. And despite its name, the Nordic Ware American-made jelly roll pans are made in the USA.
Purchase the Nordic Ware Natural Jelly Roll Pan on Amazon for $19.
Best jelly roll pan with handles: All-Clad Pro-Release Nonstick Bakeware
The All-Clad Pro-Release Nonstick Bakeware Jelly Roll Pan is a testament to the brand's quality, performance, and durability. This handled pan is easy to maneuver in the kitchen and only weighs a little over two pounds.
Our favorite thing about this pan is that the handles are easy to grab and rotate with oven mitts on, allowing you to flip and turn the pan as needed. Although the cost of the pan is slightly higher than others we've reviewed, its nonstick coating reinforced with ceramic holds up better than other cheaper products. In short, All-Clad is considered a leader in cookware for many reasons, and this pan is just a testament to that.
Purchase the All-Clad Pro-Release Nonstick Bakeware Jelly Roll Pan on Amazon for $29.99.
Best lightweight jelly roll pan: Wilton Performance Baking Pans
Lightweight pans like Wilton Performance are a simple solution for some folks who get frustrated with moving heavy baking pans. Each pan only weighs a few ounces, so it's ideal for storing and cooking food without the arm workout. It means you can keep these pans in overhead storage rather than having to make space with the rest of your baking pans and tools.
Although the anodized aluminum pan isn't as durable in preventing scratches and warping as other pans, its nonstick surface makes baking brownies and cookies a breeze. Its low price tag is icing on the cake for folks looking for an affordable starter pan.
Purchase Wilton Performance Jelly Roll Pan on Amazon for $16.11.
Best nonstick stainless steel jelly roll pan: OXO Good Grips Non-Stick Pro Jelly Roll Pan
OXO is a dependable household brand that makes products perfect for folks on a budget who don't want to sacrifice quality. We like that its Good Grips nonstick aluminum pan is made with square, rolled edges to easily move food from pan to plate, and that its non-stick coating is heavily reinforced, so it holds up better to scratching and abrasions than other brands.
Another important consideration is the micro-texture on the pan's surface which promotes better airflow and a more consistent bake. This pan's middle-of-the-road price tag makes it a reasonable investment for most people looking for a pan that will last several years without needing to be replaced.
Purchase OXO Good Grips non-stick jelly roll pan on Amazon for $21.99.
Best heavy-gauge aluminum steel jelly roll pan: Williams Sonoma Traditionaltouch Jelly Roll Pan
If you don't mind using parchment paper to line your jelly roll pan, consider the Traditionaltouch Jelly Roll Pan from Williams Sonoma. Like the retailer's Goldtouch nonstick pan, the Traditionaltouch offers one of the best heat distribution metrics on the market because of its diamond-textured surface, which encourages airflow and ensures your recipes come out perfect, from toasted nuts to pastries. This pan is also equipped with Williams Sonoma's signature wire reinforcement, which makes it less prone to warping than a flimsy, cheap baking pan.
Purchase Traditionaltouch Jelly Roll Pan from Williams Sonoma for $24.95.
Best carbon steel jelly roll pan: Chicago Metallic Pro Non-Stick Jelly Roll Baking Pan
Is warping a common occurrence for your pans? If so, consider investing in carbon steel rather than aluminum. These pans are heavy yet durable, non-stick, and will last years in your cabinet.
The only major downside of this pan is that it isn't rated for temperatures above what other nonstick aluminum jelly roll pans can fathom (450 degrees Fahrenheit), so you can't use it for broiling. However, for people who like the feeling of a heavy-gauge pan without the heavy-gauge price tag, this is the one to go for.
Purchase Chicago Metallic Pro Non-Stick Jelly Roll Baking Pan on Amazon for $13.99.
Best ceramic jelly roll pan: Caraway Non-Stick Ceramic Baking Sheet
Ceramic pans are for the veggie roasters and sheet pan dinner lovers of the world. The Caraway ceramic pans are some of the best cookware brands you can purchase because they are made with a non-stick and non-toxic coating free of PFOAs and PTFEs — which is perfect for easy cleaning.
The pans can stand temperatures up to 550 F, so they are a more versatile item to have in your kitchen. You can use them for both baking and serving, which adds to the utility and justifies the slightly more expensive price tag. And at two pounds, they're not obnoxiously heavy.
Purchase Caraway Non-Stick Ceramic Baking Sheet from Amazon for $40.50
Best jelly roll pan set: Hongbake Baking Sheet Pan Set
Buying a set of baking pans is a more practical and financially feasible option is practical for folks outfitting their kitchens for the first time. Consider the Hongbake non-stick baking sheet set, which includes a quarter-sheet pan, jelly roll pan, and full-sheet pan.
These pans are made from durable carbon steel with a silicone coating, making them easy to clean and serve with. In addition, the diamond texture pattern on the bottom of the pans promotes airflow, which means perfectly browned chocolate chip cookies.
Purchase Hongbake Baking Sheet Pan Set from Amazon for $28.99.
Best deep-pan: Meleg Otthon Jelly Roll Pan
A pan with high sides is a good investment for cooking and baking, so we recommend adding the Meleg Otthon to your cart. It offers pans in several heights, including a 2.35-inch for all-around use and a 4-inch pan for extra thick brownies. These pans are lightweight at just over a pound, making storage and cooking easy for any space. The pans are also dishwasher safe and made of professional-grade stainless steel, so you won't have to worry about warping or wear.
Purchase Meleg Otthon Jelly Roll Pan on Amazon for $21.99
Best pan-rack combo: USA Pan Jelly Roll and Baking Cooling Rack
First-time homeowners can agree that buying things in sets is often a good idea, including this jelly roll and baking cooling rack combo set from USA Pan. The pans, paired with a layer of Americoat non-toxic silicon coating, are corrugated for easy release of food, while the rack comes with a thoughtful, heavy-duty design to ensure that your cookies and cakes achieve maximum airflow. This set was designed with the baker in mind, which we appreciate.
Purchase USA Pan Jelly Roll and Baking Cooling Rack on Amazon for $29.79