The 20 Best Winter Ice Cream Flavors

When the weather outside is frightful, you probably want to curl up inside with a cozy blanket and a hot spoonful of apple cobbler. But while warm desserts might be the hug you think your belly needs, seasonal ice cream flavors are another way to get into the mood for the holidays. With every flavor under the sun including gingerbread, eggnog, and peppermint, there is bound to be a holiday flavor to suit any set of tastebuds. 

While we would argue the best way to eat holiday ice cream is straight from the pint with a trusty metal spoon, you can also add a scoop of your favorite seasonal ice cream to a cup and cover it with espresso for a take on an affogato. Or, add a medley of toppings and holiday sprinkles for a seasonal sundae. And before you ask, eating ice cream for breakfast on Christmas morning is okay. Here are some brands offering delicious holiday ice cream flavors this season. 

Talenti is a manufacturer of gelato, sorbet, and layered desserts available in most major grocery stores. Unlike traditional ice cream, gelato has a lower fat content (because more milk than cream is used in producing it) and a creamier texture. Gelato can come in many of the same flavors as conventional ice cream, and Talenti has mastered that formula with its peppermint bark gelato. You won't miss the unctuous texture of ice cream with this smooth-blended gelato, flavored with a white chocolate peppermint base with flakes of semi-sweet chocolate churned in. While we would recommend pairing this ice cream with a guilty pleasure Hallmark movie and warm blanket, we could also see serving a scoop as an after-dinner treat for any holiday dinner party. 

Alden's Organic is a smaller-scale ice cream manufacturer that produces delicious, organic dairy and non-dairy ice creams. The peppermint twist ice cream is a limited edition flavor that comes in both 1.5-quart packages and ice cream bars. You'll find delicious hues of red and white in each bite along with the flavors of peppermint and white chocolate swirls. 

Alden's Organic includes chopped peppermint candy pieces in their ice cream — which is more mint-forward than other holiday peppermint ice cream offerings on the market. There is a fair distribution of these pieces throughout the ice cream, so your molars won't feel like they're going to town on a candy cane. The bars come individually packaged in boxed of three with a delicious chocolate coating and easy-to-hold stick for easy (and joyful) eating. We warn you that it may be hard to just eat one.

Blue Bell offers several holiday-inspired ice cream flavors including Christmas cookies: a sugar cookie ice cream base with chunks of chocolate chip cookie cookies, sugar cookies, and snickerdoodle cookies dotted with red sprinkles and swirled with green icing. Although it might sound like a lot going on at once, this ice cream is a Christmas miracle.

Blue Bell has the best selection of holiday flavors compared to other brands on our list. Its peppermint bark flavor is made with mint ice cream littered with dark chocolate and peppermint bark pieces. The peppermint flavor is a bit more simple with just a mint ice cream with peppermint pieces while the eggnog rounds out the group with a whole half-gallon of creamy nutmeg flavor with a whipped topping swirl.

Jeni's Mexican hot chocolate ice cream started the company's entire lineup of creative and delicious ice cream flavors. The brand blends a smooth chocolate ice cream with flecks of hot Vietnamese cinnamon and a bit of hot cayenne. It's the perfect blend of sweet heat. The flavors are immaculate and smooth and provide a reprieve from the drowning sweetness that comes with many wintertime ice cream flavors.

For folks looking for other seasonal holiday flavors, Jeni's also offers a boozy eggnog with sweet whiskey undertones, white chocolate peppermint (it's like peppermint bark, made all the more perfect with a hint of sea salt), oh-so-nutty pistachio macaron, and a cranberry crumble with the essence of brown sugar and walnuts. But, we're partial to the Mexican hot chocolate, if you couldn't tell.

There has to be at least one option for the dairy-free folks, right? So Delicious Dairy Free makes a cashew-milk based snickerdoodle ice cream with delicious swirls of warm cinnamon and sugar. The ice cream is also gluten-free, and certifiably delicious. And for those folks eyeing the "cashew" component of this vegan ice cream, think again. Cashews, along with the help of coconut milk, mimic the texture and creaminess of traditional ice cream. 

So Delicious' dairy-free ice cream line also contains almond milk, coconut milk, soy milk, oat milk, and the new "Wondermilk" (made with a medley of alternative milks for maximum creaminess). We only wish there were more holiday flavor options to choose from — along with a way to purchase even larger containers of So Delicious. 

Häagen-Dazs is a go-to ice cream brand in the pint department, so we were pleasantly surprised to see Häagen-Dazs peppermint bark come around this holiday season. You'll get the full-body creaminess that Häagen-Dazs is so well-renowned for, as well as a creamy white chocolate ice cream base with tossed with dark chocolate and peppermint candy pieces. The biggest downside to buying this flavor is its comparative price to other competitors, especially because Häagen-Dazs is exclusively pints rather than any larger sizes. Plus, you get what you pay for when you go with Häagen-Dazs, so it might be worth keeping a pint of the good stuff locked in the back of your freezer for when last-minute holiday cravings emerge.

Mayfield Creamery offers two limited edition seasonal flavors including peppermint stick, made with a peppermint ice cream base along with red and green peppermint candies, and snow cream, a super creamy vanilla that is marketed to taste like "filling a bowl with freshly fallen snow, milk, sugar and flavoring with vanilla." Do we think it's a gimmick to sell more vanilla ice cream? We'll let you decide. In the meantime, we'll enjoy the peppermint stick ice cream sandwiched between two homemade peppermint patty cookies in our version of a holiday cookie sandwich. These cookies are the perfect textural addition to peppermint stick ice cream, especially when the cookies are coated in a thick layer of decadent melted dark chocolate.

Oddfellows is no stranger to making fun ice cream flavors. This year, their holiday movie night collection ($69.99 at the time of publication) contains five flavors that you're bound to find nowhere else. Buddi's Spaghetti Sundae is a maple ice cream base interspersed with chocolate cookie crumbs, mini marshmallows, M&M's, Sno-Caps, and corn nuts — made to mimic Buddy the Elf's favorite food groups: candy, candy canes, candy corns, and syrup (via Cleveland19). 

Moosenog, meanwhile, includes an eggnog ice cream with an upgrade of peanut butter cups and fudge swirls. Banoffee Pie is perfect for somewhat adventurous eaters; it has a banana ice cream base, graham soil, and Dulce de Leche swirl. Chocolate ice cream traditionalists will enjoy the Oh Fudge with malted milk chocolate ice cream, brownies, and fudge. The Razzleberry Dressing rounds out the bunch with the fruitiness of blackberry and raspberry jam. You'll love having a case of Oddfellows in your freezer for holiday movie nights, no matter what you're watching.

Salt & Straw is a delicious ice cream brand known for its innovative flavors. For folks who don't have the pleasure of living near a scoop shop, Salt & Straw will ship to your door with a minimum purchase of five pints. The brand offers several holiday flavors like spiked eggnog with flavor notes of vanilla, sherry, nutmeg, and dark agave and gingerbread cookie ice cream. 

But our two favorite seasonal flavors from Salt & Straw are a bit more unconventional. Its almond brittle with salted ganache is the perfect truffle-y and brined chocolate mixture that's flavorful and uniquely mature. We also love that Salt & Straw has a seasonal vegan option: the great cookie swap. This flavor is perfect for folks who can't decide what kind of cookie to pick from the cookie tray. You'll get undertones of snickerdoodle cookies, marionberry thumbprints, almond bark, molasses cookies, and coconutty macaroons. It's chaotic — but oh so beautiful.

Nothing goes quite like the holiday season like booze. And there's no shortage of it with Tipsy Scoop's holiday collection. The Holiday Favorites 5-pack includes a sampler of some of Tipsy Scoop's holiday-inspired ice creams like the Sugar Cookie Martini infused with vodka, Minty Hot Chocolate infused with creme de menthe, Ballotin Caramel Turtle Chocolate Whiskey, Waffles and Whiskey (with yummy brown sugar syrup), and Cookies and Cream Mudslide. Each pack (priced at $72 at the time of publication) is a great gift set for the holiday season, it even comes with a gift box perfect for underneath the tree.

For folks who like the charcuterie part of the holidays, Tipsy Scoop also has you covered with a collaboration with Murray's: a wine and cheese ice cream collection. This six-pack of pints includes two pints of each Brie & Bubbles, Blue Cheese & Port, and Chardonnay & Goat Cheese. Albeit unconventional, these ice cream flavors are bound to make you think about something other than the blustery weather outside.