The 12 Best Spots To Grab A Cannoli In New Jersey

One of the best pieces of cinematic advice ever offered comes from "The Godfather" when Peter Clemenza famously tells Rocco Lampone to "leave the gun, take the cannoli." Violence begets violence, after all, while cannolis only bring joy. Cannoli, like the Corleones, come from Sicily. In their home country, they're typically made with sheep's milk ricotta – cannoli, that is, not Corleones. This isn't always the case, though, as La Gazzetta Italiana says that cows' milk ricotta is the preferred alternative in eastern Sicily, so cannoli from this region aren't too dissimilar from the ones we know in the United States.

As to who makes the best cannoli, we're going to buck tradition here and say it's probably not anyone's nonna unless they have a great deal of patience and time on their hands. Cannoli shells can be a real pain in the you-know-what, especially since you need cannoli molds to make them. The wise nonna knows to start with store-bought shells (or perhaps microwaved pizzelle?) or, better yet, outsource all cannoli-making to the professionals at an Italian bakery. And the wisest nonna would surely choose a bakery located in New Jersey, which is one of the states where the Italian-American population numbers are in the double digits, percent-wise (per the National Italian American Foundation). While it would be tough to pick the Garden State's very best cannoli, it sure is fun to try. Should you be up to the task, here's a list of our favorites to get you started.

With a place named Cannoli World, you don't even have to ask what's on the menu. No disappointments in store here — yes, it has fresh cannoli, and plenty of them. One thing the name doesn't tell you, though, is a fun fact about the man baking the cannoli: Back in the day (the early '90s, per YouTube), Tony (aka Tom) Ricca was signed to WWE (then known as WWF) and faced off in the squared circle against Hall of Famer Hacksaw Jim Duggan. Ricca didn't exactly have a HOF-worthy in-ring career himself as Cagematch reveals that he only wrestled sporadically in the indies for the rest of the decade, but if there was a cannoli Hall of Fame he'd be in there for sure.

The best thing about Cannoli World's cannoli is the variety. Purists will find the traditional kind here, but there are also blueberry cannoli (Hammond lays claim to being the "blueberry capital of the world," per NJ.com), banana cream pie cannoli, pumpkin pie cannoli, s'mores cannoli, and even cannoli made with beer and wine. And that's naming just a few! At the moment, the menu lists 30 different cannoli, but through the years the bakery claims to have concocted thousands of different varieties. Cookies and cakes are available, as well, but why would you ever need to stray from the cannoli? It may take a while to work through them all, but the effort will be worth it, — we promise.

Gencarelli's Bakery first opened its Bloomfield location back in 1975 as a bread-only operation, but this family-owned enterprise soon expanded into pastries as well. The move was obviously a successful one, as the 25th anniversary year saw the opening of the Wayne location. Today both bakeries are open 364 days out of the year, open on Christmas but closed on New Year's Day. Go figure. (maybe the Gencarellis are really into the Rose Bowl Parade or something). Both locations also offer an extensive line of specialty breads, pies, donuts, danishes, cookies, specially-decorated cakes, and, of course, pastries.

While many items in the pastry case look pretty tempting (those Portuguese egg tarts, the rum babas, oh, and are those raspberry-almond tarts?) we're here for the cannoli, and these do not disappoint. They come in the standard options: small or large, sugar-sprinkled or dipped in chocolate. Whichever kind you choose, they'll be freshly filled, crunchy-sweet, and utterly delightful. There is one other item of interest to cannoli lovers we need to mention, though, and that's a cannoli cake that is not only filled with cannoli cream but is also topped off with a whole cannoli. No idea how you'd slice into that, but it would undoubtedly make for a glorious, delicious wreck once you did.

While many of the bakeries on this list are old-school Italian American, L'Arte della Pasticceria is something a bit different, and perhaps one where Food Network aficionados will feel more at home as the staff are less likely to laugh at and may even echo your Giada-style pronunciation. Rather than having roots that date back to the 20th or even 19th centuries, L'Arte della Pasticceria is a product of the 20-teens (2013, to be exact), and in keeping with its era bills presents as an artisanal (aka hipsterish) pastry shop.

L'Arte della Pasticceria 's cannoli, as might be expected, are mini works of art made with ingredients not sold at Key Food. They come in two varieties: The cannoli alla crema are filled with vanilla pastry cream, with the ends of the filling (not the shell itself) dipped in chocolate bits, while the cannoli alla ricotta are made with sheep's milk cheese in the western Sicilian style. While this type of ricotta is slightly tangier than the more familiar cow's-milk version, it gives the cannoli a slightly cheesecake-ish flavor that contrasts nicely with the chocolate chips mixed into the filling, plus we're also partial to the chopped pistachios used to adorn the ends.

Mattarello Bakery & Cafe is three businesses in one. It's a bakery, of course, and it's also a café in the coffee house sense of the word with selections running to Italian specialties including crema di caffe (Italy's answer to dalgona coffee) and affogato (espresso + gelato). It's third string is a market that sells a selection of Italian imported items such as olive oils, jams, and candies. The market even has several cannoli-related items including a candy bar made with cannoli cream and chips and a box of imported, shelf-stable Sicilian cannoli in an assortment of chocolate, almond, pistachio, and lemon flavors.

Mattarello's bakery, however, is where you'll find the real gems. The fresh cannoli come in regular and large (no miniatures here), with the former offering a choice of traditional or, for a slight upcharge, chocolate-dipped shells. The filling in all cases is made of ricotta with chocolate chips, but Mattarello's signature touch is a candied orange peel sliver atop each cannoli with makes for a wonderful, slightly bittersweet, contrast with the creamy filling.

Randazzo's Pastry Shop is pretty ecumenical in its offerings. On the deli side of the menu are sandwiches with names like "The Guido," "The Godfather," and "Rocky Balboa," each made with Italian cold cuts, but there are also all-American offerings like "Roosevelt" and "American President" made with turkey and roast beef, respectively. Over on the bakery side, the theme is even more noticeable with hamantaschen, crumbs with Linzer tarts, tres leches cake, and, of course, cannoli.

The cannoli at Randazzo's come in the standard range of small or large sizes with traditional or chocolate-dipped shells and have chocolate chips in the filling. If you can't get enough of this filling, well, join the club. Try it in a cannoli cup (a slightly neater way to get your fix), then go for broke and order a whole cannoli cake as well. Randazzo's actually has two different types of cannoli cake, with one being a cheesecake and the other a rum cake. Decisions, decisions.

Sorrento Bakery & Deli is a great place to go if you're feeling extra-hungry but don't want to fill up on cannoli alone. Here you can precede your pastries with an actual meal — the deli has an impressive array of sandwiches, many made with tasty Italian cold cuts like capicola, soppressata, mortadella, and prosciutto, but there are also a few meat-free options such as grilled eggplant with mozzarella and roasted peppers. If you want something more than a sandwich, you can also order from a small selection of entrees including chicken cacciatore and baked ziti.

For dessert, of course, you must have a cannoli and you should definitely pick up a box to go, as well. The shells are of the sturdy sort, so they won't get too soggy on the ride home, but even if they do soften up just a tad, it won't matter too much as Sorrento's day-old cannoli are perfectly palatable. (We can't speak to the second day, though, since no cannoli ever lasts that long around us.) Sorrento Bakery's cannoli come in standard and miniature varieties, traditional and chocolate, and yes, there's also a "Big Cannoli" stuffed with smaller ones that can even be decorated for your special occasion upon request.