Here's The Best Peppermint Ice Cream Your Money Can Buy
By Anna Staropoli
A few brands have truly perfected peppermint ice cream. In Tasting Table's ranking of store-bought peppermint ice creams, we found Graeter's to be the best.
Graeter's is great because it doesn't rely solely on peppermint chunks to provide the flavor. The creamy base is made in a French pot freezer, making it smooth and silky.
The brand doesn’t skimp on peppermint, either. The ice cream comes chock full of peppermint oil and is enhanced by additional pieces of crunchy candy cane.
Graeter's only operates its physical retail locations in Illinois, Ohio, Kentucky, Pennsylvania, and Indiana, but you can order cartons online and have them shipped nationwide.