Playing Ketchup

An L.A.-made Heinz alternative
Molonay Tubilderborst savory ketchup

Nick Coe came into a few hundred pounds of tomatoes last fall while he was running his Molonay Tubilderborst pop-up at Señor Fish.

The Garden Of... was offloading the last of its late-season crop, and Coe boiled them down into ketchup, which he served with butternut-squash tater tots.

The pop-up’s moment has passed, but last week Coe cooked his first full-scale commercial batch of Molonay Tubilderborst ketchup ($6 for 12 ounces), born of that chance experiment and currently available at Lindy & Grundy and the Altadena Farmers’ Market.

Coe researched 19th-century recipes, found an organic California-grown tomato paste, parsed the FDA’s Code of Federal Regulations entry on ketchup, and contracted the centenarian Sierra Madre food-preserving company E. Waldo Ward to do the production and bottling.

The result is three separate ketchups: spicy, savory and curry. Each offers a darker, less sweet and more complexly spiced alternative to the Heinz standard. The difference in the flavors results from slight tweaks to a base spice mix, which Coe allows he built on the historic trinity of allspice, cloves and cinnamon.

But you’ll have to guess at what the so-called exotic additions are, because Coe isn’t talking.

Lindy & Grundy, 801 N. Fairfax Ave., Mid-City, 323-951-0804 or lindyandgrundy.comAltadena Farmers’ Market, 600 W. Palm St., Altadena,

Lindy & Grundy 801 N. Fairfax Ave. Los Angeles CA 90046 323-951-0804 The Altadena Farmers' Market 600 W. Palm St. Altadena CA 91001
Want the inside scoop?
get the latest recipes, news and hacks from tasting table
Please check your inbox to verify your email address.

Learn More About the Altadena Farmers' Market

Next Step

Pie Not?

Keep Reading

Around the Web

Get the Tasting Table newsletter for adventurous eaters everywhere